AllModern is the better pick if you’re price-conscious, need fast delivery, or are furnishing a temporary space. It’s budget-friendly, efficient, and stylish for the moment. West Elm, on the other hand, leans into long-term value—better materials, white glove service, and unique, sustainable designs—but at a 25–40% premium.
Pros and Cons Summary Table
Choose AllModern if:
You’re on a tighter budget.
You want trendy, on-point modern pieces.
You need furniture quickly.
You’re furnishing a temporary space or want accent pieces.
Choose West Elm if:
You have a mid-range to higher budget.
You prioritize sustainable and ethically sourced materials.
You’re looking for more unique, curated pieces.
You desire higher quality and durability for long-term investment pieces.
Price Range
AllModern skews more affordable, especially at the entry level. You’ll find clean-lined basics at prices West Elm rarely matches. But West Elm stretches higher—particularly for statement pieces, custom upholstery, or solid wood. The gap widens in the upper tiers.
Sofas
AllModern’s lineup starts at just $320 for an armless sleeper and tops out at $7,613 for a high-end leather design with wide arms and tuned proportions. Most of their mid-range sofas fall between $600 and $2,000.
West Elm’s sofas begin around $559 (for the compact Bogart loveseat) and go all the way up to $8,695 for the Harmony Modular Leather Reclining Sofa—built for comfort, and priced for it too. Expect more contract-grade options and customization, which bumps up the cost.
Beds
At AllModern, beds range from $146 for solid wood basics like the Amaryn, to $7,096 for a high-end, modular leather platform bed with a floating silhouette and integrated storage. There’s a wide span of styles at sub-$1,000 price points.
West Elm starts higher. Entry-level platform beds begin at $349, and the top-tier Perlman bed—made of reclaimed oak—runs just over $6,000. Most of their beds fall in the $1,000–$2,500 range, especially if you’re after solid wood and built-in sustainability.
Dining Tables
AllModern has some of the lowest starting prices—like the $95 Chansoo bar table—but goes as high as $5,399 for grand-scale reclaimed oak. The sweet spot for stylish, functional dining tables tends to sit around $300–$1,500.
West Elm’s prices begin near $199 (clearance) for a glass-top round table and climb up to $14,629 for the Farrow Communal Table with solid wood and built-in power. Their average range is noticeably higher, often $1,000–$3,000 for dining pieces with contract-grade durability.
On average, West Elm runs about 25–40% more expensive than AllModern across comparable categories—especially when you factor in customization, materials, and contract-grade builds. If budget is tight, AllModern offers better value. But for design impact and longevity, West Elm makes its case.
Delivery
AllModern keeps things fast and flexible. Small items usually show up in a week or less, and most in-stock furniture ships within a few days. Larger pieces can take 4–17 days to arrive, depending on where you live. Orders over $35 ship free, and that even covers some sofas with white glove delivery. Need full assembly and packaging taken away? That’s about $99–$149, and you’ll see all the options clearly during checkout.
West Elm takes a more structured approach. Small items arrive in 5–7 business days, but furniture delivery depends on your location and what’s in stock. Most large items include white glove service by default—unpacking, room placement, assembly—but it costs more. Shipping is rarely free unless you catch a promotion, and even then, it’s often limited to specific items or smaller goods.
AllModern takes the lead—quicker delivery, fewer fees, and easier access to free shipping.
Assembly
AllModern often requires you to assemble the furniture yourself, especially for smaller or mid-sized pieces. However, they offer optional paid assembly through Angi and a full-service delivery upgrade for some large items.
West Elm typically includes assembly for large furniture through their White Glove Delivery service, which handles setup and packaging removal. For smaller or doorstep deliveries, you’ll likely be assembling it yourself.
Return Policy
AllModern gives you 30 days to send most items back—but you’re covering the shipping. Smaller returns might cost you $10–$49, while large furniture can run $50–$200 or more.
Everything has to be in original condition and packaging. No returns on clearance, custom, or assembled items. Refunds hit your account in about 3–5 days after they inspect it.
West Elm also allows 30 days, but some quick-ship upholstery has a 7-day limit. You’ll need your receipt, and items should be unassembled.
Returns can be done in-store or online, but return shipping is on you unless the item was damaged. Expect your refund in 7–10 days. Custom and monogrammed items are final sale.
West Elm gives you the perk of in-store returns. AllModern keeps it simple online—but return shipping always comes out of your refund.