AllModern is a solid pick for modern design lovers. If you know your style—clean, modern, minimal—AllModern makes shopping easier. But if you’re on a budget, Wayfair offers more variety and the chance to score a serious deal.
Let’s break it down.
Pricing
AllModern targets shoppers who love modern, and Scandinavian-inspired design. Their prices for similar items can be a bit higher— $400–$700 for an accent chair or $900+ for a sofa.
Wayfair, on the other hand, is all about options—and lots of them. They offer everything from ultra-budget finds to higher-end pieces, with dynamic pricing that shifts based on demand and seasonality. You’ll see ottomans starting at $50, sofas under $500, and bedding from just $20.
At Wayfair you’ll find everything—$39 nightstands, $2,999 sectionals, and every possible aesthetic in between. Prices shift constantly. Sales pop up out of nowhere.
All Modern Price Range Examples:
- Accent Chairs: $400–$700+
- Sofas: ~$900–$2,000+
- Rugs: $200+
- Bar Stool Sets: $190+
- Beds: ~$1,000+
Wayfair Price Range Examples:
- Ottomans: From $50
- Bedding: From $20
- Rugs: From $50
- Accent Chairs: From $125
- Sofas: Under $500 (some premium options higher)
- Beds: Under $700
Quality
AllModern nor Wayfair makes anything themselves. They don’t own factories. They don’t build furniture. They source from a giant pool of suppliers—some great, some… not. Quality? – It’s inconsistent. You might get something that feels solid and looks sharp. Or you might get something that wobbles out of the box and feels like it was made from cardboard and hope.
AllModern: A Focused Approach to Modern Furniture
AllModern keeps the focus tight. Modern, mid-century, Scandi. That focus means fewer gimmicky “shabby chic” paint jobs or weird faux-distressed finishes. The overall look feels more refined. And sometimes, the build does too.
Dining chairs from AllModern offered a stylish look and surprising comfort—some of the most comfortable in their price range. However, they arrived lighter than expected and feel a bit delicate. They’re holding up, but not built for aggressive leaning.
Some of their sofas are made in the U.S., which usually means better materials and joinery. Mortise-and-tenon stuff. Denser foam. More care. You just have to dig a little to find them—they don’t exactly advertise it front and center.
Wayfair: Quantity Over Consistency
Wayfair is all about volume. Every brand, every style, every price point. That means the good stuff is in there—but so is the junk. And it’s not always easy to tell the difference.
One faux leather chair held up for a year. Another, nearly identical in price and appearance, started peeling within two months. Same listing style—completely different outcome.
Reviews are your lifeline here. Read them carefully. Look for photos. Watch for red flags—missing parts, broken legs, weird smells, confusing assembly. If three people say the screws didn’t line up, believe them.
On both sites, the product description might sound perfect. But what shows up at your door? That’s a gamble.
Wayfair vs AllModern: Shipping Time and Cost
Wayfair and AllModern operate under the same parent company, so their shipping policies are nearly identical—but there are still a few things worth noting if you’re deciding where to order from.
Shipping Time
For small items, both sites offer:
- Ground shipping: 1–7 business days
- Expedited: 2 business days
- Express: 1 business day
These are shipped through standard carriers like UPS or FedEx.
Shipping Cost
The base structure is nearly the same on both sites:
- Free shipping on most orders over $35
- Flat-rate shipping for smaller orders (around $4.99–$6.99)
- Additional charges for white glove or room-of-choice delivery
- Surcharges for Alaska, Hawaii, or U.S. Territories
International shipping: Wayfair ships to select countries; AllModern is U.S.-only
AllModern: Clean, Fast, and More White Glove Options
AllModern just feels a little more polished when it comes to delivery. Boxes show up looking intact. Items are packed like someone actually cared. No mystery stains. No loose hardware rattling around.
Shipping is often faster, especially for in-stock items. Dining chairs have arrived within three days of ordering. White Glove delivery is promoted more frequently—and occasionally included at no extra cost. Items are brought inside, unpacked, assembled, and the packaging is hauled away. No hassle.
Less back-and-forth, fewer missed calls from freight companies asking if you’ll be home between 9 a.m. and next Thursday.
Wayfair: Wildcard Experience
Wayfair is a toss-up. Some orders fly to your doorstep. Others take so long you forget you bought them. It all depends on the supplier—and there are a lot of them.
Yes, shipping is usually free over $35. But that only gets it to your curb or front door. If you want it in the room or assembled, expect to pay extra. And during big events like Way Day, prepare for delays. Everything slows down when half the internet is ordering new headboards.
Also, tracking updates aren’t always accurate. I’ve had packages show “in transit” for days, then suddenly appear. So yeah, be ready for surprises.
Returns
Both Wayfair and AllModern give you 30 days to return most items—but there are strings attached. Your item must be unused, ideally still in the original packaging, and definitely not half-assembled. Clearance, custom, or open-box finds? Final sale. No take-backs.
And unless your item shows up damaged, you’re paying the return shipping. For a full-size sofa or dining table, that refund hit can be steep.
Returns on AllModern tend to feel a bit more streamlined. With fewer suppliers and a tighter selection, the process is clearer and more predictable. That said, they don’t cut slack for buyer’s remorse—especially over color.
So if that “charcoal” chair turns out to be more soft gray than smoky black, you can still return it—but you’ll be covering shipping, and your refund will be minus that cost.
In short: the process works, but it’s not forgiving.
Wayfair has a much bigger marketplace feel. That means more options—but less consistency. Some returns are fast and painless. Others are a headache, with delayed labels or confusing instructions depending on which supplier fulfilled your order.
Tip: Keep every bit of packaging until you’re 100% sure the item is staying. And inspect everything right away—scratches, dents, missing parts. If there’s a problem, report it immediately or you risk missing the window.